top of page

What we (haven’t) learned in the mountains and the glens

9 minutes ago
4 min read

Retired minister Erik Cramb shares thoughts on a defining modern Scottish drama.


BBC4 recently showed the film of John McGrath’s 1973 ‘ceilidh’ play The Cheviot, the Stag and the Black Black Oil when it was performed by 7:84 in the highland village hall at Dorie. Its moving opening scene shows the packed audience singing “These are my mountains and I’m coming home and this is my glen, the braes of my childhood will know me again.”


The drama begins with the aftermath of the battle of Culloden in 1746. Vividly tracing the ensuing brutal oppression inflicted upon highland communities, the banning of the Gaelic language and the wearing of plaid, the actors highlight 60 years of oppression where the first step was the destroying of the culture of the indigenous inhabitants.


By the beginning of the 19th century, the Edinburgh lawyer Patrick Sellar persuades the land owner the Duke of Sutherland that his estates are losing money, the rents paid by the people are too low and it would be more profitable to replace the people with a hardy breed of sheep - the Cheviot – the choice of breed informed by a careful recognition of the harshness of the climate … but no careful thought applied to the consequences for the inhabitants. 


The notorious Clearances began in 1814, driven by the landowners, the banks and the lawyers - collectively the ruling class. The advantages to them of high finance based on lies and underhand deals are expounded in comic fashion in the play, but the serious duplicity is made clear.  Soldiers are brought in from the south and the people are driven from the land, their meagre homes routinely burnt to the ground, a brutality underpinned as being legitimate in upholding ‘The Law’. 


The women, who in many cases led the resistance, not only suffered extreme cruelty at the hands of the police and soldiers - but were also branded as sinners by the Kirk.  In the play, a weedy looking minister tells his rebellious congregation that they must desist from law breaking and violence or they would suffer at the final judgement and be condemned to everlasting burning in the fire of Hell. There is no concept on the minister’s part that the women he called his ‘flock’ were already in a living hell as they watched their houses being torched by the soldiers of the ruling classes to make way for flock upon flock of dumb sheep.


The law these women were rebelling against was the Law of Capitalism - not that it was called that by the ruling classes.  Then, as now, that ‘law’ is that profits must be used unhindered to create more profits for the holders of capital who were the beneficiaries of the huge profits being accrued from the industrial revolution in the south where the inhabitants of the slums of Glasgow were no better off than the highlanders being driven from their crofts.  The Press, then as now, was not only on the side of the ruling class but was owned by them.  The ruling classes strived to make anything that hindered this process unlawful - and the results of that striving has become accepted in our modern world.  The ‘Market’ rules is the financial, political and cultural norm globally.  


Back to McGrath’s iconic play, and the Stag. A whole way of life had been destroyed by economic power, and the people cleared off the land. The highlands became the playground of the wealthy, now well established as the monarchs of the glen, more Scottish than the Scots. To this day, male members of the British Royal family including the King come to Balmoral dressed up in kilts and sporrans. The owners of much of the land were developing great shooting estates with their own dress codes and ‘highland balls’ served by grouse beaters and other sundry subservient local employees. Unless economic power is in the hands of the people, not only will their culture be destroyed but it will be treated with derision and appropriated and distorted.


Finally, the play turns to The Black Black Oil. In the 1960s, the oil discovered under the sea bed off the Scottish north coast was gifted to mainly American companies (Conico, Occidental, Shell, Esso, Mobil, Texaco) as well as to BP, British Petroleum.  A new ruling class descended upon the north east of Scotland, and house prices in Aberdeen escalated beyond the reach of young Aberdonians.  A new culture was taking over in the shape of the global oil industry.  Experienced Americans took all the plum jobs, and this culture was often referred to as the new wild west.  A new exploitative set of working terms and conditions prevailed in terms of wages and conditions, especially the absence of health and safety. (Piper Alpha was still to come).


The conclusion of the play was that in the 20th century the people do not own the land nor control the land any more than in the time of the arrival of the great sheep. Multinational conglomerates rip out the natural resources of lands all around the globe, and the play poses the question to us all - have we yet learned anything from the Clearances?

 

Published 20 November 2026


The name of the theatre company which John McGrath and his colleagues founded came from a statistic on (mis) distribution of wealth in the (dis) United Kingdom, published in The Economist in 1966, that 7% of the population owned 84% of the wealth.

 

bottom of page